Mytholder (mytholder) wrote,
Mytholder
mytholder

Thinking out loud: Why Games Are Not Yet Art

Reading this blog entry from James Wallis sparked an odd line of thought.
An awful lot of rambling and burblingCollapse )
Right. Half three, I've been rambling for more than an hour. To summarise:
  • A Portrait of the Artist is art.
  • A hypertext of that book is also art.
  • A hypothetical superset of all possible narratives of which A Portrait of the Artist is but one path is also, probably, art.
  • A Portrait of the Warlock of Firetop Mountain is somewhat less likely to be art.
  • That's because it's a game, and for a game, you need a goal, and you need to make informed choices to get to that goal.
  • Goals are weird. Most art doesn't present the reader with a goal. Games do.
  • We're not good at presenting the information needed to make informed choices to the player.
  • We're not good at handling choices in a work of art, either.
  • It's very late, and this is not helping write Hawkmoon adventures.


More on informed choices and goals later.
Tags: gaming, rambling
Subscribe

  • Twitter/News in Brief

    I've only got time to twitter at the moment - should I feed my twitter over here on livejournal as so many others do? Also, news in brief: *…

  • Dark Heresy

    I've started running a pair of linked Dark Heresy campaigns. Campaign blog here.

  • Unknown Armies campaign, session one

    My closing remarks: "Ok, Washington, you're lying on the floor, dying after Hoover emptied the second shotgun barrel into your chest. The wizard's…

  • Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 29 comments

  • Twitter/News in Brief

    I've only got time to twitter at the moment - should I feed my twitter over here on livejournal as so many others do? Also, news in brief: *…

  • Dark Heresy

    I've started running a pair of linked Dark Heresy campaigns. Campaign blog here.

  • Unknown Armies campaign, session one

    My closing remarks: "Ok, Washington, you're lying on the floor, dying after Hoover emptied the second shotgun barrel into your chest. The wizard's…